Dear Scotland: contemporary views on how and why the union harms scotland

‘Scotland is not a colony’, and other myths that need cleared up

SEVERAL commentators last week [w/b 15.10.23] insisted that “Scotland is not a colony”, and that British rule over Scotland cannot be seen as colonial in nature. This bears some clearing up.

On the most trivial level, ­“Scotland is not a colony” because “colony” was one particular form of governance within the British Empire, which never applied to ­Scotland.

But many other parts of the British Empire were not officially “colonies” either. Some, like Malaya and the Trucial States, were protectorates. Some, like Canada after 1867 and South Africa after 1910, were “dominions”. Some, like Gibraltar and Bermuda, are now called “overseas territories”.

“Scotland is not a colony” because imperial rule over Scotland was established by treaty, not conquest. But that also applies to much of the British Empire. Imperialism-by-treaty was a common mode of expansion.

The imperial ­power just needs to apply the right pressure to the right people. Find the parcel of rogues and pay them off. When that fails to pacify people, then send the redcoats in to uphold the treaty – there is a clear line between 1707 and 1746.

“Scotland is not a colony” because the ­Scottish elite actively cooperated with and ­benefitted from imperial rule. Of course they did. Every successful empire brings native elites on board – and has done since the first Gaul, seeing what side his bread was buttered, donned a toga and learnt Latin.

Being absorbed into an empire can be ­beneficial for these assimilated elites. They have economic opportunities that would ­otherwise be denied to them. Above all, they gain ­protection against their own people.

There might even be a “sahib” class of elite ­natives who have been so socialised into the imperial ruling system that they are trusted to manage things, so long as they do so in the ultimate interests of the Empire and not in the interests of their fellow countrymen. There are still a lot of these Scottish sahibs about, quietly running Scotland and keeping a lid on things.

“Scotland is not a colony” because we have self-government. So did most colonies. ­Colonialism entails the subordination of high politics to imperial ends – a colony loses the ­power to determine its own destiny on the world stage, to make war and peace, to ­conduct ­international affairs. Low politics may be left in local hands. Indeed, general patterns of rule across the British Empire were hands-off. Most colonies had devolved legislatures, with broad powers over their own affairs, but ­subject to London’s ultimate veto. Does that sound ­familiar?

“Scotland is not a colony” because Scotland has seats in Westminster. So did Ireland. But somehow the same people who deny Scotland’s colonial status are happy to acknowledge the ­colonial nature of British rule in Ireland.

“Scotland is not a colony” because Scotland was a coloniser – as if the two were mutually incompatible. Unfortunately for those who like their historical narratives clear and simple, the world is not divided into goodies and baddies. Some, looking at their grim opportunities in Scotland, willingly took the boat. Others, looking at their burning clachans, were rounded up and forced to the quayside. That is how easily the colonised become colonisers.

“Scotland is not a colony” because Scots fought proudly and bravery in the British ­Empire’s wars. That’s also a common feature of empires. A colonially governed country is a ­useful source of canon fodder, to be sure; ­colonised people with “martial traditions” like Punjabi Sikhs or Scottish Highlanders can be put to work on behalf of the imperial scheme.

“Scotland is not a colony” because there was no cultural oppression. That must be why this article is being written in English, while the ­native languages of Scotland are preserved like curios on signposts.

“Scotland is not a colony” because ­colonialism is all about racism, and therefore it cannot ­happen to white people. This is the most ­ridiculous argument of all. Go tell it to the Ukrainians.

“Scotland is not a colony” because others had it worse. Aye, and some had it better. Most were given independence when they asked for it. Scotland is denied that opportunity.

In short, to deny the colonial nature of the British Empire’s rule over Scotland is either to misunderstand the complexity and ­ambiguity of the British Empire or else to downplay the ­reality of Scotland’s subjection to British ­imperial rule.

The good news is that all empires die. They get to a pinnacle where all lies at their feet, and end as a ruin in the desert with the ­inscription: “Look upon my works, ye mighty, and despair.”

The final death throes of the British ­Empire can be easy or hard. The easy way is to ­allow the peaceful, democratic, transition to ­independence, as it was done across much of the world by post-war British governments. The hard way is to fight it and lose.

Which is Sir Keir Starmer to emulate: Harold Macmillan or Lord North?

Website Note: Macmillan is remembered for his “Winds of Change” speech when he facilitated the decolonisation of British African colonies and their move toward independence. Lord North, on the other hand, was the British prime minister who hung on to and eventually lost the American colonies, ie the USA.

John Drummond

Sovereignty resides with the Scottish people and always has

WHY is the Scottish government failing to comply with the expressed sovereign will of the people of Scotland? The Scottish Parliament was not abolished in 1707, it merely stopped sitting. Since the Declaration of Arbroath in 1320, sovereignty has resided with the...

What the UK doesn’t want you to know

The oleaginous Michael Gove was caught with his pants down at the Covid Enquiry in Edinburgh. After charging the Scottish Government with political opportunism, KC Jamie Dawson brandished Gove’s Cabinet paper, delivered just before Johnson parachuted into...

How the Union has robbed the Scottish People

Since the 1707 Treaty of Union, Scotland’s wealth has been stolen and exploited by our larger “partner” in an ongoing act of colonisation. The definition of colonialism is economic exploitation by a dominant power that exercises political control over its colony. This...

A Rogue in a Parcel O’ Them

The new Scottish Labour MP Michael Shanks will speak at the Scotland in Union Burns supper later this month. Quelle surprise.  During the by-election campaign Shanks said the constitutional debate was something ‘we have to completely...

A clear route to Independence lies in front of the SNP

THE letter from William Golden in last Thursday’s National echoes similar calls which have been endlessly recorded in the paper for the last six months. The answer to William’s call is never – we will never see the SNP put forward an exciting,...

In an independent Scotland, we could sack the government

Labour MP Ian Murray says the first duty of government is to keep its citizens safe. But he doesn’t say how a Starmer Labour government can conceivably do so when it is studiously copying its policies from a Tory playbook which has delivered the discredited,...

The Common Good or Private Profit?

It’s said that the US Congress is the best that money can buy. Corporate cash and the revolving door between it and Wall Street, Big Pharma, Big Tech, Big Oil, and the military industrial complex has destroyed democratic accountability. Where America goes, so goes its...

How the Public Good is replaced by the pursuit of profit

It’s said that the US Congress is the best that money can buy. Corporate cash and the revolving door between it and Wall Street, Big Pharma, Big Tech, Big Oil, and the military industrial complex has destroyed democratic accountability. Where America goes, so goes its...

England’s Reliance on Scotland

Unionists often write that Scotland is indebted to the UK. In fact, the reverse is true. The British state's plans to use oil and gas to “power-up Britain” relies on 90% of its supply from Scotland. It's not just old energy that England steals from Scotland. A quarter...

The UK Needs Scotland

Douglas Ross giving economic advice to Scotland is lunacy. We’d be crazy to let the Tories continue their wrecking ball policies by electing even more of them in Scotland. This is the party that brought us over a decade of austerity that has gutted public services,...