Dear Scotland: contemporary views on how and why the union harms scotland

How the Union has robbed the Scottish People

Since the 1707 Treaty of Union, Scotland’s wealth has been stolen and exploited by our larger “partner” in an ongoing act of colonisation.

The definition of colonialism is economic exploitation by a dominant power that exercises political control over its colony. This describes Scotland in the UK where we have no control over our land or resources and our MPs are overwhelmingly and consistently outvoted by English MPs. Because Scotland has no veto over English decisions, the union is a complete sham.

In 1707, Scotland had 1.1 million people, 20% of the population of England and Wales. Today, Scotland has just 8.1% of the UK population, of which over a quarter were born in England and Wales. This is one of the largest single non-war depopulations in western Europe for a country of Scotland’s size and was a direct consequence of Scotland being in the union.

The union has resulted in Scotland being under-developed and poorer than it should be. Scotland’s economy lags far behind its prosperous Nordic neighbours, and over a fifth of Scots live in poverty. Most of Scotland’s assets have been sold to foreign entities with the Scottish People receiving very little to nothing. None of the major economic sectors are Scottish-owned and even our universities are headed by Anglo Scots or people from England.

This theft of Scotland’s assets is a clear violation of the Treaty and Acts of Union. Since the year 840, the Crown of Scotland was and remains the Community of the Realm, the People. The People, not the monarch or parliament, were sovereign and had the right to elect or depose a ruler who did not govern in their interests.

By contrast, the Crown of England, established in 1066, was the monarch, who owned all the land and exercised political and legal sovereignty over England and its People. This sovereignty was transferred to the English Parliament in 1689 which is where the modern doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty comes from. 

The two Crowns are fundamentally different. The English Crown concept has been illegally imposed onto Scotland. And it is under this English ‘Crown right’ that the theft of Scotland’s territorial assets has been legitimised. The Treaty of Union never enabled this theft nor did it have the legal authority to agree to it. The Treaty is a fraud. It masks England’s illegal annexation of Scotland and is why the People’s wealth has been stolen from them.

What follows are examples of how the union has robbed the Scottish People of their sovereign wealth.

Scotland’s Ports

Scotland was once a great seafaring and trading nation, with active ports around our vast coastline that were owned by the local communities, the Burghs. These ports supported the entire economy, creating much of the wealth of the town and sustaining the local population. They raised substantial revenues from local taxes on goods and ships, enabling the Burghs to re-invest in new port infrastructure. 

In the 1960s, the UK government transferred port ownership from councils to private trusts which operated in the vested interests of the trustees, not the community. In 1991, the UK Government allowed the trusts to sell the ports to private companies, with half the revenue going to the UK and half to the trust owners. Burghs received nothing. The owners then sold the ports to offshore private equity firms at inflated prices. The private equity model doesn’t allow for investment in new infrastructure because the ports are bought in leveraged transactions with high levels of debt. Port profits that used to flow to the the local community are then used to pay the interest on this debt mountain.

To see what the return of local port ownership could bring to Scotland’s communities, look at the Northern Isles in Orkney and Shetland where the councils continue to own the ports. They were able to build up sovereign wealth funds from massive oil tanker trading, charging dues (taxes) on ships and goods and on ferries and cruise ships. This provides for a hefty additional income to these councils which employ large numbers of people in maritime activity. It also generates surpluses for general use. In Shetland the oil fund helped pay for leisure centres and swimming pools in most parishes and outer isles, and also helped fund major road upgrades and maintain internal ferry services.  

Scotland’s North Sea Oil

In 1975, the UK Government faced a dilemma: how to exploit the potential of its new North Sea oil fields, 90% of which lay in Scottish waters, without fuelling demands for Scottish independence. So, it buried the evidence in the incendiary McCrone Report, authored by Professor Gavin McCrone.

McCrone wrote that an independent Scotland’s budget surpluses as a result of the oil boom would be so large as to be “embarrassing”. Scotland’s currency “would become the hardest in Europe, with the exception perhaps of the Norwegian Kronor.”

The comparison with Norway particularly worried Westminster. Independent Norway in the mid 1970s was about to capitalise on an oil boom that today has made Norway one of the world’s richest nations with a sovereign wealth fund worth over $1 trillion. Scotland’s oil and gas reserves exceeded Norway’s so had we been independent, our wealth would arguably be even greater.

Oil would make Scotland far wealthier than England, putting it in a position to lend heavily to its indebted southern neighbour. At the time of the report, the SNP estimated that North Sea oil would yield £800 million per year by 1980. McCrone criticised this estimate as being far too low, putting the sum at £3 billion.  

No wonder Westminster’s mandarins instructed that the 19-page report be classified and buried for the next 30 years until a Freedom of Information request finally unearthed it.

But by then, the damage had been done. The entire value of North Sea oil – hundreds of billions – had flowed to the UK Treasury where it was squandered on tax cuts, mass privatisations, English infrastructure projects such as the Channel Tunnel, Eurostar, Canary Wharf, and, of course, nuclear weapons, stored half an hour from Scotland’s largest city.

Scottish oil has repeatedly bailed out a sinking UK economy. In return, Thatcher shut down Scottish industries, destroying whole communities. The incalculable harm from both the theft of our oil and the decimation of our industrial base reverberates to this day.

Scotland’s Sea Border

Scotland’s national borders comprise one land border with England and several sea borders, one with England and several others with the Isle of Man, Ireland, Faeroe, Norway, Denmark, Germany and the Netherlands. However, the UK Government has twice illegally moved Scotland’s sea border with England north, once in 1968 and again in 1999. 

In 1968, the UK government ignored Scotland’s constitutional North Sea true border that starts from the centre of the mouth of the River Tweed (55°45’53.28”N) and extends due east, and illegally moved it north to Lamberton (55°48’42″N) by imposing the Continental Shelf (Jurisdiction) Order 1968.

This violated Article 15 of the International Law of the Sea, which recognises a nation’s “historic title” to sea boundaries. Since the 14th century, Scotland has had “historic title” to the mouth of the River Tweed as the latitude of the sea border with England.

Then on the eve of the opening of the Scottish Parliament in April 1999, Tony Blair’s government illegally promulgated ‘The Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order,’ which secretly moved Scotland’s North Sea border to the north, transferring some 6,255 statute square miles (5,540 nautical square miles) of Scottish waters to English jurisdiction, in clear violation of the Treaty and Acts of Union. Blair’s government feared that after devolution Scotland would leave the UK, so this was a preemption. 

Significantly, at least twelve producing oil and gas fields are in the stolen North Sea area. Each of these fields sends taxes and licence fees to the UK Treasury. Not one penny of this money from the fields is credited to Scotland, thus understating the GERS accounts to Scotland’s disadvantage. Naturally, the UK Treasury does not publish information to allow the understatement to be calculated. 

Ten years later, the London Times published an article, ‘Secret plan to deprive independent Scotland of North Sea oil fields’. It stated, “Treasury officials advised that the boundaries of Scotland’s coastal waters should be redrawn and a new sector created to “neutralise” Scotland’s claim to North Sea oil – a step that was taken.”

Scotland’s Renewable Energy

Scotland has abundant renewable energy resources, which are cheaper and cleaner than fossil fuels. Scotland generates nearly a quarter of the UK’s renewable energy and 85% of its hydropower and is a major European player. Based on current projected installation capacity, Scotland is on course to deliver nearly half of Europe’s offshore wind grid supply by 2035, over halfof the entire offshore grid potential in the Mediterranean Basin.

In 2022, renewables provided 97% of Scotland’s electricity consumption, led by onshore wind at 78%, hydro at 12% and the remainder from solar, wave, tidal and biomass.

The UK has played down Scotland’s renewables wealth, just as it did our oil wealth. The reason is simple. It wants us to believe we can’t possibly prosper outside the union when the truth is England can’t survive without unfettered access to our resources. 

The Scottish Government, a colonial arm of Westminster rule, has a poor record of managing those resources. In January 2022, it auctioned offshore wind licenses for 5,000 square miles of the Scottish seabed, setting a maximum one-off price of just £700 million. Some ‘auction’! The licenses went to energy giants including Shell, BP, French TotalEnergies, Spanish Iberdrola and Danish Orsted. At around the same time, an area off Long Island, New York, 25% the size of the Scottish area, sold for $4.37 billion.

The second great rip-off has started. Scottish renewables are currently being sent to England with no compensation and no new businesses and jobs for the Scottish people. To appreciate the sheer scale of the rip-off, in 2021, 35 TWh (1 TWh = 1 billion KWh) of renewables worth £600 billion a year was cabled to England with no compensation for the Scottish People. By 2030, the UK plans to increase this to 124 TWh, worth an estimated £2.12 trillion!

The 35 TWh of energy that Scotland sent to GB in 2021 is enough to power Scotland 3.5 times over. The expected future growth is even more staggering, with the 124 TWh of renewable energy able to power all of Scotland’s 2.5 million homes more than 12 times over.

Not only does it not control its energy assets, Scotland doesn’t own the energy transmission and distribution system, either. The UK’s privatised National Grid levies the highest electricity standing charges in the UK on Scots, who pay 50% more than Londoners. And Scottish generators pay the highest rates to connect to the grid in Europe, despite Scotland accounting for 52% of the total UK network. Naturally, Westminster is loathe to change a system where Scotland so generously subsidises the rest of the UK. 

But that’s what colonialism is all about. The colony’s resources are extracted and then sold back to them at a premium by the coloniser. It’s why a quarter of all Scottish households can’t afford to heat their homes.

Scotland as the UK’s nuclear waste dump

For decades, Scotland has been the UK’s dumping ground for radioactive nuclear waste. The Solway Firth and Irish Sea are polluted with 60 years of discharges from Windscale (Sellafield) and radioactivity is measurable in the River Cree. Areas in Caithness around the Dounreay experimental fast nuclear reactors won’t be safe for use for 300 years. SEPA announced in 2011 that it was not possible to remove lethal particles of spent nuclear fuel from the seabed near Dounreay and HMS Vulcan because the contamination is beyond recovery. The MOD is dismantling 27 nuclear submarines at Rosyth, burying the nuclear waste in new nearby dumps.

The Dalgety Bay shoreline on the Fife coast is contaminated with high-level radioactive waste from WWII and Kirkcudbright Bay is heavily contaminated with over 6000 depleted uranium shells from an armament testing range at Dundrennan.

In 2020, the MOD applied to SEPA increase discharges of radioactive waste from its nuclear submarine bases at Faslane and Coulport into the Firth of Clyde by up to 50 times. The liquid waste comes from the reactors that power the Royal Navy’s submarines and from the processing of Trident nuclear warheads. It will be discharged from Faslane into the Gareloch nearby via a proposed pipeline. (And there are plans to increase the number of nuclear submarines at Faslane with the UK’s new Dreadnought-class.) The move has been condemned by Dr Ian Fairlie, a radiation expert and former UK government advisor, who said not enough work has been done on estimating the increases in the levels of tritium and cobalt-60 in the flora and fauna.

Despite being a signatory to the 1972 London Dumping Convention for the prevention of marine pollution and the 2006 Protocol to the Convention that ban the dumping of radioactive materials and waste, the UK has tried to circumvent these international agreements by nominating ‘Scottish Sea Areas’ such as the Minch in northwest Scotland for dumping obsolete nuclear submarines and a fishing ground, Stormy Bank to the west of Hoy in Orkney, for the burial of nuclear waste.

In 1975, the UK government named Mullwharchar in the Dungeon Hills, a sub-range of the Galloway Hills, as their chosen site for the “UK high level nuclear waste dump.” Their reasoning was not because the granite would contain the waste – it won’t – but because it deemed the local communities to be “sparsely populated”, unsophisticated and therefore unlikely to protest successfully.” Mullwaharchar was spared its fate by a level 5 earthquake in December 1979, an event the nuclear industry had claimed would never happen in Galloway.   

There is no secure disposal method for nuclear waste and neither is it a solution to climate change. In 2022, former heads of nuclear power regulationin the U.S., Germany, and France, along with the former secretary to the UK’s government radiation protection committee, issued a joint statement that, “Nuclear is just not part of any feasible strategy that could counter climate change,” because of its cost, the risk of accidents and nuclear waste. And yet the UK has announced it will build at least 6 more nuclear power plants in England and is desperately blasting the Irish sea bed and Solway Firth in a damaging and fruitless search for a place to store nuclear waste.

The UK thinks it doesn’t need permission to dispose of its radioactive waste in Scotland, just as it thinks it doesn’t need permission to site its weapons of mass destruction half an hour from Scotland’s largest city.

For over three centuries, the UK has gotten away with the theft of Scotland’s resources, the defilement of its land, and the suppression of its People, language and culture. The only way to end it is for the sovereign Scottish People to take their independence from an entity that masquerades as a union but is in reality a colonial overlord.

Leah Gunn Barrett

Sovereignty resides with the Scottish people and always has

WHY is the Scottish government failing to comply with the expressed sovereign will of the people of Scotland? The Scottish Parliament was not abolished in 1707, it merely stopped sitting. Since the Declaration of Arbroath in 1320, sovereignty has resided with the...

What the UK doesn’t want you to know

The oleaginous Michael Gove was caught with his pants down at the Covid Enquiry in Edinburgh. After charging the Scottish Government with political opportunism, KC Jamie Dawson brandished Gove’s Cabinet paper, delivered just before Johnson parachuted into...

A Rogue in a Parcel O’ Them

The new Scottish Labour MP Michael Shanks will speak at the Scotland in Union Burns supper later this month. Quelle surprise.  During the by-election campaign Shanks said the constitutional debate was something ‘we have to completely...

A clear route to Independence lies in front of the SNP

THE letter from William Golden in last Thursday’s National echoes similar calls which have been endlessly recorded in the paper for the last six months. The answer to William’s call is never – we will never see the SNP put forward an exciting,...

In an independent Scotland, we could sack the government

Labour MP Ian Murray says the first duty of government is to keep its citizens safe. But he doesn’t say how a Starmer Labour government can conceivably do so when it is studiously copying its policies from a Tory playbook which has delivered the discredited,...

‘Scotland is not a colony’, and other myths that need cleared up

SEVERAL commentators last week [w/b 15.10.23] insisted that “Scotland is not a colony”, and that British rule over Scotland cannot be seen as colonial in nature. This bears some clearing up. On the most trivial level, ­“Scotland is not a colony” because “colony” was...

The Common Good or Private Profit?

It’s said that the US Congress is the best that money can buy. Corporate cash and the revolving door between it and Wall Street, Big Pharma, Big Tech, Big Oil, and the military industrial complex has destroyed democratic accountability. Where America goes, so goes its...

How the Public Good is replaced by the pursuit of profit

It’s said that the US Congress is the best that money can buy. Corporate cash and the revolving door between it and Wall Street, Big Pharma, Big Tech, Big Oil, and the military industrial complex has destroyed democratic accountability. Where America goes, so goes its...

England’s Reliance on Scotland

Unionists often write that Scotland is indebted to the UK. In fact, the reverse is true. The British state's plans to use oil and gas to “power-up Britain” relies on 90% of its supply from Scotland. It's not just old energy that England steals from Scotland. A quarter...

The UK Needs Scotland

Douglas Ross giving economic advice to Scotland is lunacy. We’d be crazy to let the Tories continue their wrecking ball policies by electing even more of them in Scotland. This is the party that brought us over a decade of austerity that has gutted public services,...